======>
Pramudyo:
STORY ONE
In my opionin, Diva’s first story is true, because the reason why she didn’t bring her suitcase made sense and losing her suitcase is an unlucky thing. About hanif’s story, it kinda confuse me because it could be true or lie, but ultimately i believed that it was false because swimming into deep water for just saving a slipper didn’t make any sense. Kabik’s story is true, because simply it was coherent. Nicholas’s story is way to extreme and i refuse to believe it. My Story about movies was a lie, because i loved movies. Raja’s story is definitely a lie because fighting over a girl as an elementary student is way too early and didn’t made sense. Ricky’s story is truee. Sabrina’s story is very interesting, because staying in foreign country without parents is scary, but somehow i believed it as a truth. Bagas’s story is a truth, its fun to hear a story from someone about their passion on something. Vivi’s story is way too scary, i believe its a lie.
STORY TWO
Hanif’s second story is truee, because it made much more sense compared to his first story, and i believe its hard to not eat chicken for a very long time. Kabik’s second story is a lie, i dont know why but i just felt that it was a lie. Ricky’s story is a lie. Vivi’s second story made much more sense compared to her first one, but disliking instant noodles? That is weird but it could be true. Raja’s second story is true, i never had experience any sleepwalking in my life, but after hearing his story, it made want to feel how is it like to expereinced a sleepwalking. Sabrina’s story is lie, because leaving your house because of justin bieber?? really? I dont believe it. Bagas’s second story is a lie, because it didnt sound convincing to me. Diva’s second story is a lie, because stabbing yourself with a pencil? I did not believe it. Nicho’s second story is true because he’s pretty much talking about this class hahaha.
From my two stories, the one about lessons i learned from losing football matches is the true one, the other one about movies is a lie.
======>
Bagas:
Diva
I think the second story is more believable, because it is possible for a teenager to stab themselves because it is true that most of teenagers are reckless and most likely to be less cautious to whatever the consequences of what they will do to themselves.
Hanif
The first story is more believable because, children tends to be more active doing unreasonable things, and Hanif is a reckless kid. He put his life on the line just to safe his dad’s slippers. And because the second story is not convincing enough because it is impossible that someone never eat chicken for 18 years.
Kabik
Both stories have the details needed to make me think that both is the truth, but the second story is more convincing for me, because it is a typical story a high school girl will experience as soon as they sees someone that meet their expectations about the guy of their dream, with so much of good expectation and become obsessed with those boys.
Pramudyo
The second one is more believable as competition between schools are a common thing during high school years and in a competition there will be a winner or postponed winner (loser) and from losing a competition it is true as what Pram said that there are a lot of things that can be extracted from that kind of situation and work it out as a team.
Nico
The second one is the truth, I am 100% sure because it happened to me also. Simply because we are in the same class, every single class.
Raja
The first story is the truth, because from my experience war between school gangs is a common thing for most of the high school in Indonesia. Most of the time ,school will try to prevent such things to happen and try to interfere similar to what the school in Raja’s story have done to prevent the “war” or tawuran.
Ricky
The second story is the truth because Ricky is a guy who tries to be a man with a healthy lifestyle and what Ricky experience also happened to me for several times so I can relate more to the second story.
Sabrina
I can assure anyone that the 2nd story of Sabrina is the most believable because for a teenage girl which obsessed to their idol, in this case Justin Bieber . they will do anything for their idol, including running away from home just to get their newest album.
Vivi
The 1st story is more convincing because the details she put in the first story actually
Supported the flow of the story rather than the 2nd story , and the other thing is who can be sick with instant noodles.
======>
Kabik:
HANIF
*It is TRUE that Hanif’s dad lost his slipper in the ocean, I think it happens all the time to many people, once you get to the water with your slippers on it could get easily drifted.
# It is FALSE that Hanif didn’t eat any chicken product until 2018 he tasted chicken and started liking it and eat it almost everyday without any specific reasons.
RAJA
*It is FALSE that Raja had tawuran when he was in senior High School, I can understand that mostly boys are obsessed with girls a little bit too much that they decided to fight to get the girls. But I can not believe that Raja would do this because he seems like a person who don’t like violence.
# It is TRUE that he had sleepwalking and took a shower without realizing it, this story is somehow sounds more possible for me because I know that some people have sleeping issues.
SABRINA
*It is FALSE that Sabrina is left all alone in japan without her parents for four days, it was because her grandfather is passed away that her parents went back to Indonesia, I think no one would continue their trip when they know one of the family member is sick or passed away.
#It is TRUE that Sabrina was runaway from home for about 30 minutes only, she said that she was a big fan of Justin Bieber. I can relate. once when I was a kid I runaway from home because my dad forced me to join the choir of my church and I didn’t want to. So I know exactly how she felt at that time, I totally understand.
VIVI
*It is FALSE that Vivi went hiking with her dad and some of his friends. Well, she sounds so convincing but after I listened to the second of her podcast I do think that this story is false.
# it is TRUE that Vivi does not like eat instant noodle, as I know, Vivi is having a healty lifestyle, she is very concern about what she eats, once when we had a lunch together she had the healthy menu while me, I don’t really care about my diet.
DIVA
*it is FALSE that Diva had traveled without any suitcases at all because she lost them on the way to Korea, I think the international flight would have a decent facility and take care of the passenger’s suitcases well.
# It is TRUE that Diva had stabbed 3 herself three times with pencil accidently and left 2 scars on her hand, she said that it was happened when she was in elementary, I know most of the elementary students are very clumsy and reckless so I can say that it was true.
PRAMUDYO
*It is FALSE that Pramudyo is hate watching movies, as teenagers I believe we spend most of our times watching movies in the spare time. Especially nowadays we have these famous and booming movies like The Avengers, Taken, The Purge, etc.
# It is TRUE that Pramudyo is learns a lot from his losing at the football game. Losing is not always means that you have failed. Like what he said in the podcast that by losing and competing you learn how to work as a team.
RICKY
* It is TRUE that Ricky was a third grader and scaring a second grader by knocking their doors. Again, as I said before, as a student of elementary it is very normal and we can find it common for children teasing their friends.
# It is FALSE that Ricky met a rabbit dog near his house in Bogor, because I don’t know what rabbit dog is and if it is a rabbit dog with bubbles around its mouth that indicates this animal is dangerous and his house is not safe.
BAGAS
*It is FALSE that Bagas’s life is changes because of boxing, he said that he did the boxing because of his ex-girlfriend, I don’t think it is true that he let himself do the physical exercise in order to make his ex happy with his body. For me it is sound like a body shaming, and I don’t think that the girlfriends would let the boyfriends do something like this.
# it is TRUE that Bagas have been playing drums for years, and performed in several cafes. He looks like he plays drums. I mean, I don’t really know how to identify drummers from their appearance but Im just sure that he plays drum.
NICHO
*It is FALSE that he went to Semarang and was drown in the pool, this story is could be happened in reality but his second story makes me sure that this first story of him is has never been true.
# It is true that Nicho do the assignments in the toilet, because I can hear clearly that he actually did it. This is very funny and smart that he shares this story and help me easily to justify the answer.
Notes:
(*) Means PODCAST 1
(#) Means PODCAST 2
======>
Nicho:
First Story
Kabik’s story is a true story because all the details are necessary and make sense for me.
Raja’s story is a true story because i knew that Raja’s school was pretty ‘gentho’ so this is actually a believable story coming from his high school life.
Sabrina’s story is a false story because i do not think any parents would leave their children alone especially in the place they are not familar with for a few days.
Hanif’s story is a true story because i think as a child, we have this sort of spontaneous reaction which is expressed by Hanif jumping to the water.
Bagas’ story is a false story because i can not imagine Bagas with 100kg body could be exist in the pass. I do not think Bagas is that kind of person who would get bothered by his girlfriend’s opinions about physical appearences. The last one, is it even possible to hide broken nose to your parents? Twice?!
Ricky’s story is a true story because i could imagine Ricky being a little bit cruel to someone.
Diva’s story is a false story since she did not sound like she was upset at all.
Vivi’s story is a true story because it makes sense and she seems to be really excited when she was talking about it.
Pramudyo’s story is a false story because it is like a very exaggerated hatred over small things that does not deserve that much of hate.
Second Story
Hanif’s second story is a false story because i think chickens are common food and all of the sudden like it when moved into Jogja even eat it almost everyday? It does not make any sense to me.
Kabik’s second story is a false story because it contains hyperbole that does not fit with what i think about girls. Girls are harder to fall in love than boys.
Pramudyo’s story is a true story because he sounds very sincere and has a deep feeling which is a sign when you are talking about your passion or learn something in life.
Ricky’s story is a false story because i do not think he expressed enough fear that he should have when he met a rabies infected rabbit dog.
Vivi’s story is a false story because i think she sounds like reading wikipedia’s fact and had this kind of flat emotion. These are the features of typical made out stories because there is no feeling towards the story.
Raja’s story is not a true story. Although i never have any sleepwalking before but i do not think that you could do a shower while maintaining your asleep condition.
Sabrina’s story is a true story because i do not know which one is a true story or not. I am just guessing at this point, her both stories was very hard to decide whether they are true or false. Well done Sabrina.
Bagas’ story is a true story. To be honest, i am confused. I just compare this story to the other one and decide which one is more belivable. Those whether intentional or unintentional delaying for this story and fluent story telling for the first one did a really good job on making me confused.
Diva’s second story is a true story because i think it is very common to be a reckless kid and it is more believable than the other one.
Confession
For my story, the first one actually a false story. I really did have a drowning accident but it was in a swallow pool so my father could bring me up to the surface with ease and without the passed out part.
For my second story is actually a true story. I had this accidental Statistics 1 class that i need to attend and then i realized in the morning that EWS assigment need to be submitted before 12. So what i did is that i went to the bathroom and did all of the the assigments there!
======>
Sabrina:
Diva
I think the second story is false. The reason why is because I think it is just impossible for Diva to stabbed her hands THREE TIMES. I mean like if it was twice maybe i'll believe her. Eventhough I thought the first story was false but when I heard the second one I decided the first one might be true.
Hanif
It is kinda confusing but I think the second one is true. I personally don't eat rice at all (ever since I was 3). Rice is somehow scary for me. Like when I eat something and then there is rice in it, I would stop eating. So I can relate to Hanif on his second story.
Kabik
Her second story, in my opinion, can be true. My reason is simple. I've been in that kind of moment once. And also, her first story is not suspicious at all which makes me suspicious of her. She might want to trick us!
Nicho
His second story sounds so convincing! I heard something, is it water or what? Or is it just an effect? Anyway, I still want to say that the first story sounds true to me. Because he makes it too obvious with the second one. He's trying so hard! Well done, Nicho!
Pramudyo
His first story is just something. Who hates movies????? Ever since I moved to Yogyakarta, movies is like my main entertainment! Anyway Pram, This must be a lie! Sorry but I don't believe you. If he hates someone who loves movie, he hate me then.
Raja
I seriously can't tell which one is true or false. Both sounds convincing. But i'll just say that the second one, I think, is false. I mean like if you're soaked, as a normal human being, you should realize that you're soaked and woke up. But maybe Raja was too tired at that time? I don't know.
Ricky
I heard a couple weeks ago that Ricky have a house in Bogor. It is located near Mila Friday's school right? So I guess his second story might be true. Also, his first story sounds too plain that I had a thought that maybe he's trying to fool us?
Bagas
I do know that Bagas is good at playing basketball. But drums? I don't know. So i'll just say that I believed his first story more than his second story. But if you do play drums, Bagas, that is so cool! Also, it kinda amazes me how he played from cafe to cafe.
Vivi
I often talk to Vivi but I didn't know that she loves to hike! And about her second story, how can you hate instant noodles? In my opinion, it is the invention of the century. Instant noodles tasted good no matter how you eat it. Even if it is raw, it is delicious! (am I the only one who had eaten raw instant noodles?) Anyway, I think her second story is true. Just like what I stated on my comment about Hanif's story, it is possible that you hate something.
About my story, actually the story about being all alone in Japan without my parents are the true one. Kinda weird right? And I do love Justin Bieber but I am not that crazy. The only Bieber's album I have is his 3rd album. Anyway, travelling without our parents was a chaos. We didn't know where to go and we always woke up at like 11 A.M. because we always sleep late and we had nowhere to go. Such a waste of time. I mean, why would you sleep so much when you're travelling?
That's all Sir. Thank you so much.
======>
Ricky:
Diva
I’m guessing the story where she lost her suitcase was false because it would be really hard to travel when her family lost all their suitcases, they would have to prolong their visit if they lost valuable items. The other story, although seems painful and I haven’t notice her scar, is more believable because we all get clumsy sometimes.
Hanif
Hanif’s story about saving his dad’s slipper is one thousand times more believable than never liking chicken. Excluding vegans, almost everybody in this world loves chicken. So my guess is the drowning story is true.
Kabik
I don’t know Kabik well enough to guess which one is true. So, my rough guess is the story where she went to Bali with her family is true, because that’s just something so wonderful to do. While the other story, although really common, is just too boring.
Raja
Raja seems like a nice guy for me; too nice at times. Therefore, even though the sleep walking story seems sketchy and funny, I’m guessing it’s true. He is simply too nice to have a tawuran.
Nico
Nico and I got a lot of classes together, and he seems like the diligent type. He always asks questions when he is in class. Based on that, the drowning story is more plausible and the one where he did his assignment in the toilet is false.
Pramudyo
Football is a very popular sport in Indonesia, I’m not surprised if he loved it when he was a kid. For the other story where he hates movies, is not so believable. While he can dislike certain genres of movies, hating the whole medium it’s exaggerating. So the one story that is true is his football one.
Sabrina
Sabrina seems as a pretty reasonable girl, but when Justin Bieber was a hit, we were all still pre pubescent; it’s very possible that she threw a tantrum and left for a few minutes. I’m guessing the other story was false because her parent’s would probably take her and her sibling with them.
Bagas
I knew Bagas very well; he loves to talk about his past experiences with me and vice versa. Because of that I knew his love for boxing is the true story while the drum one is false.
Vivi
Vivi’s story about her inability to eat noodles seems to farfetched; one portion is never too much. While her hiking story seems more inspiring and coming from a real experience.
My own story.
The first story, where I have my first supernatural experienced, was true. I was never a believer of the supernatural, but in that moment, I can’t find a logical explanation on why I can hear someone knocking back from inside the drawer.
The second story was false. I never encountered any rabid dog. However, I did find a snake carcass when I jog in Bogor.
======>
Raja:
First Story
1. It’s a unique story , just imagine we travel to another country without any cloths and that’s
terrible. But for me it’s okay as long as we still have money and credit card. From diva story I
assume that it’s false because I believe that the officer from the flight company is able to find
it. Based on my experience anyway.
2. It’s a heroic story but somehow I don’t believe with the hanif story so I assume it’s false,
because I think that maybe someone helps you.
3. It’s an extraordinary story, Going to a restaurant with specific dress code it’s like well-planned.
I believe it is true.
4. Common story but It’s funny because until now I never hear that Nicho can swim or not so it’s
definitely true.
5. It’s very amazing you know, It is the first time I hear that there is someone that hate to watch a
movie. But one day I ever heard that Pramudyo was going to a teacher with his friend to
watch movie but I don’t know then. So I assume it’s true because for me pramudyo is a
unique person.
6. It is a true story about me anyway. So just a moment after we arrived at that school the
security bring us to the principal office, then about the newspaper It’s also true and the fact is
that until now none of my family know about this war. Lucky me right…
7. Ricky oh Ricky is that the way you scare someone. But I see that you are like funny person, IT
IS FUNNY NOT SCARY. SO I BELIEVE IT IS FALSE.
8. Going to Japan alone is an amazing story because you can test yourself while maybe in the
future you have the opportunity to live or study abroad but I believe that it is false because
Sabrina stay with her brother not alone.
9. Dear bagas. I have an important message for you, just be yourself you know if someone loves
you , you don’t have to change yourself, because what ever happened she should always love
you. But I think it’s true story
10. It’s a thriller story, going to mountain with those conditions, I think it’s false you know, from the
way you tell the story it’s very real
Second Story
1. I think it is true because I ever saw hanif ate a chicken in the orientation program.
2. I actually laugh when kabik said that she was flying. But somehow I don’t believe that kabik is
kind of person that is very easy to fly , I would say false
3. I don’t believe that pramudyo lose so many matches, maybe it’s just a few, so I believe false
4. Rabbit dog is impossible but I believe with those kind of things, maybe it is true.
5. I have the same person that hate to eat noodles so I think vivi is the one of them. It’s true let’s
say.
6. It’s true but in some way it is false because actually it was happened at night not in the
morning and anyway my mother laughed in front of the door and then I realised and woke up
in the bathroom.
7. It’s like kid habbits, the Justin Bieber addicts, I ever being someone like Sabrina , so I think it’s
true because we are same.
8. Bagas never told me that he’s a drummer, that’s why it is false, the way you told the story it’s
like you are nervous hahahah.
9. It think it is true, because I ever see someone that’s same with diva, anyway I will try to prove
it soon.
10. It’s true you know because nicho told me that he was trying to finish the assignment in the
toilet and he did it later.
======>
Diva:
For Hanif’s stories, I think that his second story is the truth one. The reason why is because the first story is too basic and he used it as a distraction so that we would think that the first one is the truth one since it is very simple. For Kabik’s stories, I think the truth one is also the second story. It is not because I think she couldn’t afford a party at a five star hotel but it is because I think that the story is way too simple for it to be truth, same as my thought on Hanif’s story. For Nicho’s stories, I think the truth one is also the second story, since his voice has an echo effect in the recording which made me convince that he was in the bathroom just as what he stated. For Pramudyo’s stories, I think that the truth one is the first one. When he was telling us about his hatred towards movies he sounded really genuine. Same goes for Raja, I also think his story that is the truth one is the second one because he sounded really genuine when he was telling the second one, the first one is believable but it sounded a bit too made up for me. Ricky’s stories got me the most confused. I honestly couldn’t tell which one was the truth one, but I’m going to say that the truth one is the second one because he made it very believable. For Sabrina’s stories, funny enough she actually told me the first story during High School. That’s when I know the second one is instantly fake since I have already heard the first one. Bagas’s stories were also really hard to guess which one is fake and which one is the truth one but I’m going to go with the first one as the truth. Lastly, for Vivi. I think that her second story is the truth one because she sounded really assertive when she was telling the story.
For my stories the fake one is the first one, but it is actually not a hundred percent a lie. It actually happened but my suitcase came back a day later.
======>
Vivi:
1. My guess on each of my friend's stories
Kabik = story 1: false, story 2: true
Sabrina = story1: false, story2: true
Diva= story 1:true, story 2:false
Hanif = story 2:false, story 1: true
Ricky = story 1:true, story 2:false
Pram= story1: false, story 2: true
Raja= story 1: true, story 2: false
Nicho= story 1: true, story 2: false
Bagas= story 1: false, story 2: true
2. Answers of my own stories:
My first story is actually false. I've never climb any mountain in my life (yet). My second story is very true. I don't like instant noodles, because it makes my stomach gassy.
======>
Hanif:
First Story
1. True. I have heard many stories about people losing their luggage in the airport
2. True (my own story)
3. True because the information was so detailed
4. False, im pretty sure that nicho is a guy who is capable of swimming
5. False, I understand people that hate a certain genre, but not people that dislike movies in general
6. False, the teacher arrived on schedule and that seems impossible
7. True, I have also experienced it in my school
8. False, when a family member passed away, usually the whole family will check this family member unless something important is going on
9. True, doing sports especially fighting sport usually changes someone’s mentality
10. True, hiking is an enjoyable thing for some people and its normal for people to do it
Second Story
1. False (My story)
2. False, looks like the experience was a bit exaggerated
3. True, I have experienced it myself and learned a lot
4. True, I would have done the same thing and it is common for rabbits to hide in bushes
5. True, people might have allergies for certain food
6. True, sleep walking is normal and maybe it is just his reflexes to start showering
7. False, I do not think that people will go that far
8. False, I do not know about people giving their position away in a band
9. False, that seems too scary
10. True, I think he is talking about the EWS task
======PREVIOUS CONTENT OF THIS BLOG POST - BELOW HERE==========
This is only for KABIK, VIVI, SABRINA, DIVA, HANIF, RYAN, RICKY, RAIHAN N., PRAMUDYO, RAJA, BAGAS and NICHO.
log-in to the EWS class with your fingerprint in U203 on Friday morning before you went to your Introduction to Business Class then ignore this because it means you were ABSENT for EWS session 5.
log-in to the EWS class with your fingerprint in U203 on Friday morning before Introduction to Business, but you don't do this task, I will cancel your 'attendance' and mark you ABSENT.
Ask questions about Task 1 in the Temporary Friday Group if you want to. But be sure to send your answers
(not to the group).
Ask in the Temporary Friday Group if you have any questions. Be sure to send your voice notes to
(not to the group).